Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Jamie]

Hey guys! So the last discussion thread will be up later today/tonight.. and since the majority of you wanted to continue them, we're gonna need to start brainstorming new scenes to start discussions about. Here are the ones already used: Season 1 -Pilot: That's me inside your head -Your art matters 1.0 & 2.0 -112 motel scene CCIPC -113 I feel it in my heart, don't you? Season 2 -210 I really do care about you, Peyton. -221 I don't ever want that to happen again. -221 You look like you needed some chocolate. -2x23 Looks like it's just you and me this summer. Season 3 -301 It's always going to be there, isn't it? -303 DLP Make out, talk, or die? -316 If I say I love you right now, will you hold it against me? -321 I love you, you know that? Season 4 -401 CODA Someone to help us hear the music in the world. -408 CODA I'm in love with you. -409 It's you. -411 I think we've waited long enough. Season 5 -505 None of my great days matter without you. -506 You said we were destined to be together. -507 scenes. -508 scenes. -518 It's still really hard. Season 6 -601 You're a mess, Lucas Scott, but you're my mess. -613 Daddy's home. -617 I can't live that life. -623 The wedding. Basically, we are going to have to come up with an additional 4 scenes per season. Obviously the most significant ones have already been used.. but there are many others as well. Try to suggest the most significant ones as possible!

[KRM]

Here are a few ideas if others are interested.  I'll think of more later. S1: LP talk after L gives P a ride home in 1.02. "I'm sorry ... for all sorts of things" 1.08 LP breakup scenes/P pushing L away 1.15/1.20.   S3: Road trip to see Ellie conversation in The Comet in 3.10 LP talk about Ellie outside hotel in 3.14 I'm not sure we'll get more out of season two.  We've already scraped the sweet frosting off the crapcake that was season 2 for LP.

[dawni3]

YAYYYYYY. Love this idea Jamie! Can we perhaps look at episodes rather than indiviudal scenes? Like all of their 1x05 scenes for example, rather than just one of them? Just a thought. ANYWAY. Ok, just my opinion; Season 1: - 1x07 (bedroom scene) - 1x11 (library scene) - 1x15 (Peyton lets him go) - 1x20 (coda scene) There arent any other worthy S2 scenes other than those we talked about! Season 3: - 3x10 (all scenes) - 3x14 (all scenes) - 3x17 (library) - 3x22 (all scenes) Season 4: - 4x02 (comet scenes) - 4x06 (coda) - 4x12 (all scenes) - 4x21 (all scenes) Season 5: - 5x01 (rivercourt scene) - 5x04 (all scenes) - 5x12 (comet/peytons speech) - 5x17 (IHY) Season 6: - 6x10 (coda) - 6x23 (coda) - 6x24 (Peyton wakes up)

[CMMBJGHB]

^ I liking those suggestions  guys! 6x24- The birth of Sawyer

[hilarie.love]

1.08: Luke beats up the guy & "I'm sorry..." 1.09: "I want all the same things you want, and I want them with you" 1.14: "I'll Wait Forever if I Have to" & "I'm in love with him.." 1.15: ALL. <3 2.01: LP at the beach and Luke putting the letter on HER door. 2.02 [?]: I forgot which episode, but it's NH's wedding party thing. And with the LP scene were he takes a picture of her leg & their eye contact during his speech. 2.21: Peyton box. 2. ?... it's where B & L talk about Peyton and how it's hard to be away from the person you care about. I'll think of the epi later. 2.22 [?]: When B & L go on a roadtrip and they talk about Peyton & the Peyton box. 3.08 [?]: I think this is the right episode, but it's where LP talk about their past and Brooke. 3.13: "There was this guy; there is this guy. I guy that I loved." 3. ?: It was where Peyton was talking with Ellie about being with a guy that was more than sex. 3.17: "I know how you are.. I'm the same way" 3.18: I forget the dialogue but they were talking about being happy 4.04: Protective scenes 4.05: All 4.06: All 4.07: All 4.10: "I have to go back" 4.14: "I want everything with you.." 4.17: Honeygrove 4.20: Bed scene 5.01: Rivercourt scene 6.15: Lake proposal 6.23: And she's my angel.

[CMMBJGHB]

2.21: Peyton box. 2. ?... it's where B & L talk about Peyton and how it's hard to be away from the person you care about. I'll think of the epi later. 2.22 [?]: When B & L go on a roadtrip and they talk about Peyton & the Peyton box. 3.13: "There was this guy; there is this guy. I guy that I loved." 3.17: "I know how you are.. I'm the same way" 4.04: Protective scenes 4.05: All 4.06: All 4.07: All 5.01: Rivercourt scene 6.15: Lake proposal 6.23: And she's my angel. love these.

[TeamLeyton4ever]

season 1 1x11 all of it. season 3 3X10-Road Trip Season 4 4x10-Lucas' dream sequence

[Jamie]

Great ideas, guys! I would prefer if we didn't do full episode discussions though. There was a few before (507/508) because of the large amount of huge LP scenes in them. But if there's only one or two, I'd prefer we focus on one.

[ishipleyton]

I like the idea. I would like to maybe discuss less obvious scenes, more subtle ones, the ones you barely talk about on a regular basis except when we actually make a thread about them. IDK I think I would like that.

[Destined4Greatness]

I like all the above. I want 6.22 - "I love you with all my heart."

[docent12]

1x04 "I guess I’m just a riddle wrapped in a mystery inside a bitc". 1x05 - "I would gladly erase my dad if it would bring back your mom" scene 1x14 Haley/Peyton scene "I just want to say I'm in love with him" 1x15 break up scene 1x20 "I couldn’t have gone and just slept with some stranger" scene 4x02 LP in the comet scene when they talk about the best day 4x04 "I could never cut you out of my life" scene 4x10 when Peyton's standing at the grave and Keith says to Lucas "She lived a good life Luke but she couldn never let go of you" or the Lucas/Keith scene in the Body Shop when they talk about Peyton 4x20 when they lay on the bed and Lucas says that's what's going to fix him 4x21 "I'm going to love you forever Lucas Scott" scene 5x04 - "he is not good enough" scene 6x10 coda scene 6x15 proposal 6x16 coda 6x21 the end scene (present - "we had the whole lifes ahead of us" "we still do" and the flashback "I always keep my promises") 6x22 "I love you with all my heart" 6x24 Lucas by Peyton's bed in hospital scenes

[hilarie.love]

1x04 "I guess I’m just a riddle wrapped in a mystery inside a bitc". 1x05 - "I would gladly erase my dad if it would bring back your mom" scene 1x20 "I couldn’t have gone and just slept with some stranger" scene Yes <33 Oh and 1.02: "Choke" & "Lonely" & In 1.04 when Luke was willing to get a crime on his record for Peyton.

[TeamLeyton4ever]

1x08-When Lucas fights that guy who drugged Peyton

[TeamLeyton4ever]

dp. 4x02 "when all your dreams come true, who standing there?" or whatever she said. lol.

[LPLover623]

Could we just do more from S1 and not have any more from S2?! LOL 1.05 "I would gladly erase my dad if it would bring back your mom" scene 1.07 bedroom scene & coda 1.08 Lucas fighting & "Im sorry.." 1.09 CODA 1.11 LP scene with reading/drawing 1.14 "I'll wait forever if i have to" & "I'm in love with him" 1.15 Lucas goes to Peyton's house & break-up 3.10 car scene on way to Ellie's 3.13 Ellie/Peyton scene "its never too late" 3.14 scene in the bed & on the steps 3.17 scene at Karen's/library scene & BP scene at end 4.02 scene in dark/comet scenes 4.04 "i would never cut you out of my life" 4.05 (Sorry Jamie!) But ALL scene 4.06 scene by the lockers/CODA 4.10 seeing Peyton by the grave 4.19 scene at school/what he wrote in Peyton;s yearbook 4.20 LP lying on the bed 5.02 LP phone call flashback/rivercourt scene 5.04 ALL scene 5.12 wedding etc 6.03 "you help me so much without saying a word" 6.07 ALL scenes 6.10 Coda 6.15 Coda 6.16 Coda 6.21 End scenes 6.22 Lucas/Jamie scene looking through box and coda 6.24 ALL scenes -- seeing as this was their last episode i think we should talk about them all

[dawni3]

I do like the suggestions everyone listed, but in reality some of the scenes people have said there isnt a lot to say beyond how awesome the scene is - like, for example, 6x03 because its a very short scene. Idk if that makes much sense, but I'd rather discuss scenes where theres a lot TO the scene and its an integral one to them rather than just the moments we like. Thats just my opinion, people might disagree (:

[CMMBJGHB]

^ I agree with that.

[docent12]

I do like the suggestions everyone listed, but in reality some of the scenes people have said there isnt a lot to say beyond how awesome the scene is - like, for example, 6x03 because its a very short scene. Idk if that makes much sense, but I'd rather discuss scenes where theres a lot TO the scene and its an integral one to them rather than just the moments we like. Thats just my opinion, people might disagree (: I agree with it

[tahajah]

i'm down for whatever (: i like the ideas mentioned above.

[Lostchic17]

YAYYYYYY. Love this idea Jamie! Can we perhaps look at episodes rather than indiviudal scenes? Like all of their 1x05 scenes for example, rather than just one of them? Just a thought. ANYWAY. Ok, just my opinion; Season 1: - 1x07 (bedroom scene) - 1x11 (library scene) - 1x15 (Peyton lets him go) - 1x20 (coda scene) There arent any other worthy S2 scenes other than those we talked about! Season 3: - 3x10 (all scenes) - 3x14 (all scenes) - 3x17 (library) - 3x22 (all scenes) Season 4: - 4x02 (comet scenes) - 4x06 (coda) - 4x12 (all scenes) - 4x21 (all scenes) Season 5: - 5x01 (rivercourt scene) - 5x04 (all scenes) - 5x12 (comet/peytons speech) - 5x17 (IHY) Season 6: - 6x10 (coda) - 6x23 (coda) - 6x24 (Peyton wakes up) Word. These are good ones.

[ishipleyton]

I agree with you Dawn. I also want to do smaller scenes or the ones we haven't discussed that much. Not always the major scenes like 4.09 Oh and 1.02: "Choke" & "Lonely" this please.

[dawni3]

^ See I dont see how we can have a discussion about this scene? Like, they describe in each other in one word; they know each other, have a connection. Like what else can we say? Or am I underappreciating the subtle moments?

[ishipleyton]

^ YES. HHAHA subtle scenes leave so much space to discuss. it is so awesome and it's fun to talk about it with everyone. like 4.09? PLEASE! What is there possibly to discuss? "awww eepic moment. it was always her.. blah" IDK it's always the same, you know?!

[blondielove]

I love all of the ones that Dawn mentioned

[dawni3]

^ YES. HHAHA subtle scenes leave so much space to discuss. it is so awesome and it's fun to talk about it with everyone. like 4.09? PLEASE! What is there possibly to discuss? "awww eepic moment. it was always her.. blah" IDK it's always the same, you know?! I agree, kind of. 4x09 is kind of special though, we could hardly NOT discuss it! But like that 1x02 scene, just as an example, is pointless to discuss as I dont get the depth its meant to have - literally, other than saying 'they instantly connected and he just knew her and saw through the facade she put on' what exactly are we all meant to say? Thanks Maggie.